This poster should strike sincere Christians as problematic for a few purposes. I will list off a few:1. The poster is itself fairly clearly blasphemous, using the Holy Names of Jesus and Mary for merely secular, political purposes... that is, in vain; this sin is very serious; the quotation of scripture (Mt 1:18, "This is how Jesus was born,") for such purposes strikes me as a violation of the Second Commandment in a similar vein;
2. The secular-minded groups are very cynically using the churches for their purposes;
3. The "Christian" churches accepting solicitations to display these posters will apparently not mind either the blasphemy or being used, perhaps because of complicity in the motivations of the secular-minded groups;
4. The posters and the groups behind them neglect to mention the cultural-political background of the events in the early life of the Holy Family, in which the Caesar's census was very clearly a bad thing - a tool of oppression;
5. It is arguably a violation of the legitimate separation of Church and State to employ churches in purely political work, although because the Census office is not actually involved with the poster, I am not sure that it is... this requires some mulling over.
USA Today has a reasonably balanced news story about the ad campaign. To register your shock and outrage, you might go to the feedback page on CivilRights.org's website. In my gut I feel there are more reasons to object strongly to this sacrilegious propaganda, but I cannot think further now, because I am still sputtering. Thanks to Mr. Dave Tenney for pointing this out to me.
No comments:
Post a Comment
Comments should:
(1) Lack ad hominems of any sort;
(2) Lack vitriol directed to specific persons;
(3) Be relevant to the post;
(4) Preferably be from named authors rather than anonymous spammers or flamers.
I may bounce comments that violate any of the above prescriptions.